Home/ Blog/ General
General

Choosing Between Silicone or Saline Filled Breast Implants

Choosing between silicone or saline filled breast implants can be overwhelming. Here are some things to consider in helping you decide:
A saline filled breast implant is inserted empty through a small incision and than inflated with saline (salt water). A silicone filled breast implant  is pre- filled with silicone gel and the scar is made larger so as to accommodate the size of the implant.
A Silicone filled implant is thought to have a more natural look and feel than saline. If a silicone filled breast implant ruptures you will not know it unless you have an MRI. You will know if a saline filled breast implant ruptures because the breast will be obviously smaller.
Leaking silicone gel is not thought to cause any health problems but can cause pain and changes in contour if the implant unknowingly ruptures. An MRI is recommended every 2 years for women who have silicone filled breast  implants. If a saline filled breast implant ruptures the body simply absorbs the salt water and the implant shell gets surgically removed.
A woman must be age 18 or older to have a saline filled breast implant placed and 22 years of age to have a silicone filled breast implant placed.
Silicone filled breast implants are more expensive than saline.
Any type of breast implant is not a lifetime device. At some point in time you may need to have additional surgery to exchange or remove the implants. Your surgeon may recommend one type of implant over another based on your body type but the decision of silicone vs. saline is ultimately yours.
To have a consultation with Dr Farhad Rafizadeh for a breast augmentation with silicone or saline filled breast implants in his Morristown New Jersey office contact us by calling 973-267-0928.

People Also Ask

Common Questions Patients Search About Breast Surgery

How much does breast augmentation cost in New Jersey?

Primary breast augmentation in Northern New Jersey typically runs $8,500 to $12,500 all-in, depending on implant type (saline, silicone gel, or Ideal Implant) and whether the case is combined with a lift. Dr. Rafizadeh quotes a flat price during the consultation that includes the surgeon's fee, anesthesia, the facility, and follow-up visits. Revision breast surgery costs more because the planes are scarred and the operation typically takes longer.

Is silicone or saline better for breast implants?

Both are FDA-approved and safe; the right choice depends on the patient's anatomy, preference, and how she values certain trade-offs. Silicone gel feels more like natural tissue and is the default for thinner patients with less native breast coverage. Saline ruptures are obvious immediately (the breast deflates), so some patients prefer that built-in monitoring. Dr. Rafizadeh also offers the Ideal Implant — a structured saline implant that feels closer to silicone with the safety profile of saline.

What's the difference between a breast lift and a breast reduction?

A breast lift (mastopexy) raises the breast and nipple position without removing significant tissue — ideal for women whose breasts are the right size but have descended. A breast reduction removes excess tissue along with raising the breast — appropriate for women whose breast size causes back, neck, or shoulder symptoms. The incisions are similar; the volume removed is what differs. Dr. Rafizadeh's North Jersey patients often combine elements of both when needed.

Is a breast lift easier to recover from than implants?

Recovery is similar in length (about 2–3 weeks back to non-vigorous activity), but the comfort curves differ. Implant patients report more pressure and chest tightness for the first week as the muscle accommodates. Lift patients report more skin tightness and incision care — the muscle is undisturbed but the skin envelope is reshaped. Both groups are typically back to office work in 7–10 days when surgery is performed under Dr. Rafizadeh's local-anesthesia-with-sedation protocol.

What is the 45-55 rule for breasts?

It's an aesthetic guideline: the ideal breast shape has roughly 45% of the volume above the nipple and 55% below, with the nipple sitting just above the inframammary fold. The rule helps surgeons decide implant placement, lift technique, and how much to elevate the nipple-areolar complex. Dr. Rafizadeh uses the 45/55 ratio as one of several proportional anchors during planning, alongside chest width, sternal notch-to-nipple distance, and the patient's own preferences.

How long do breast implants last?

Modern silicone and saline implants are not lifetime devices but are designed to last 10–20 years. Many patients get longer than that with no issue; some need an exchange sooner due to capsular contracture, rupture, or simply wanting a size change. The FDA recommends MRI or ultrasound screening for silicone implants starting at 5 years post-op, then every 2–3 years. Dr. Rafizadeh discusses long-term monitoring as part of every breast augmentation consultation.

What is the hardest cosmetic surgery to recover from?

Among breast procedures, breast reduction typically has the most involved recovery because of the tissue removed and the size of the incisions, but most patients say the pain trade-off is worth it given how much physical relief they feel almost immediately. Tummy tuck and combined mommy-makeover procedures rank higher overall on the difficulty curve. Compared to those, isolated breast lift or augmentation recovery is relatively gentle.

Ready to schedule a consultation with Dr. Rafizadeh?

Book a Consultation